Thanks for the input guys, and that link Ben.
I almost feel like the new switch I got might have something wrong with it, because nothing else really makes sense to me.
Not sure what grounds behind the headlights you mean, but I'm about to take a look at my TSM in a few minutes. Also need to find the dimmer switch, haven't had much chance to do it the past few days with work and high temps.
The reason I don't want to pull the dash isn't necessarily the difficulty, but because I'm literally this problem away from having my Eagle on the road and it will set me back again. The thing is, having it on the road will also mean having a much better place to work on it, and possibly having more hands to help also.
I checked all the fuses again, and all are good. I even replaced some for good measure. It's not acting like there is anything wrong with the wiring near the switch (the only place it was disturbed when the switch fell out) because I wiggled the wires in every spot with the lights on and nothing changed. In fact, the wires look practically brand new and are neatly wrapped behind the dash. I tried repositioning the ground wire on it because I couldn't think of anything else, still no luck.
Can anyone tell me how to go about testing the new switch? I have a cheapo multimeter, just don't know much about electrical systems yet.
Ben, I may just have to search for one of those metal screws from a Pacer in the future.