Headed down the road tonight after letting Virginia warm up for a couple minutes. About 34 degrees out.
I made it a mile or 2 down the road and noticed my temp gauge was at the very top edge of the green zone. I watch the temp gauge pretty closely and it never goes more than a couple mm from the bottom of the green zone, even in August with the A/C on. I pulled off onto a side road, put it in park, and gave it a little throttle to help the fan cool it down, no help, the temperature kept on climbing so I shut it off.
The engine didn't seem any hotter under the hood than usual, but after it cooled down for about 5 minutes I verified that the fan was spinning, the radiator and overflow tank both had coolant in them, and the radiator was hot so some coolant is getting through the system. I started it back up after it sat a bit, and the temp gauge dropped back down. I turned around to head home and swap the Eagle for my truck, and on the way back it did the same thing, the needle hit the red as I coasted into the driveway.
My first instinct is to replace the thermostat and go from there. There are a couple things that don't seem right to me. Minor, and maybe just coincidental. First, I noticed when I started it up before the overheating, that even though the car had sat outside in the cold for at least 3 hours since I drove it last, when I got in the temp gauge was sitting at the bottom of the green zone, when I think it should have had plenty of time to cool down. Same thing again a few minutes ago when I got home. The car sat from 9:30 to 1:30 and it's under 30 degrees tonight, yet the temp gauge was sitting in the green or just below it. So now I'm wondering if it was actually overheating, or if my temp sender is getting funny with me.
The other goofy thing it did tonight, is when I was driving it back home to get my truck, I had the heat and fan on full blast, and the battery/alternator dummy light on the dash was ghost lit. Not lit brightly, but just enough for me to notice it and be bothered by it. I never noticed this before. I don't think it's related to the issue at hand, but who knows. Not me.
So the big question is what do I try first? Temp sensor or thermostat? I'm pretty sure this isn't a head gasket issue, none of the signs are there. No gassy odor in the coolant, no coolant loss, nothing burning.