Well, well, well, we found our little whistle. The half shaft is wrong. Both shafts were bought at the same time, same box & part # and one has a bigger outside joint and boot. It bolted up alright and works ok except the lower ball joint grease fitting is rubbing on the boot and has worn halfway through it. This is the second time in less than a year that I have had major problems with fenco brand. This is going to cost me $75 to r&r this junk. Last time it was a six month old new fenco water pump on my van that exploded and took out the fan, clutch, belt and coolant plus a tow and $200 in labour.
Check this out, the new ball joint is even a lower profile than stock.
This is the other side, obviously smaller diameter joint.