I did the same thing - Got the Nest store's pins and they're too big. I think they are supposed to be.
What I was told is most hinges are probably buggered up (worn, whatever), so you can drill them out, and make them true again. That's why the pins are bigger.
Now, I only changed the bushings, and I used the old pins, and in less then a year, they're getting sloppy again. So I don't know if getting NOS pins and bushings would help, or I'm gonna have to drill mine out.
The thing I didn't like about drilling them out, is how to drill them straight without all the equipment to keep them true. I don't trust myself enough.
Maybe it doesn't matter that much, I just don't want to mess it up.
Luckily, I really only have to do the Driver's door.