The problem (I have heard) with just changing the clutch, is that you run the risk of loosing the refrigerant charge if done on the car. It would be best to have the refrigerant recovered first. Changing the clutch may require the seal to be replaced as well. It is also harder to replace the clutch with the compressor mounted to the engine. If you remove the compressor and have to replace the clutch, coil and seal, you might as well just change the entire unit. Sometimes a "bag of worms" is opened when something like this is done. You would not want to go through the work and expense changing the clutch, only to have the seal start leaking afterward (if not replaced while you are in there). That is why the suggestion to go with the Sanden. You would end up with a NEW and more efficient compressor, and it may end up costing about the same in the long run. You need to remember that the York compressor is 30+ years old, and has the technology to go with it (also 30+ years old).